The Official Student News Site of Parkway West High

Pathfinder

The Official Student News Site of Parkway West High

Pathfinder

The Official Student News Site of Parkway West High

Pathfinder

They can’t be trusted

How social media and campaign ads enable misinformation
This+photo+illustration+is+inspired+by+the+copious+political+attack+ads+plastered+over+all+news+and+local+stations+in+the+St.+Louis+Metro+area.+These+commercials+exploit+current+event+issues+by+using+the+biggest+concerns+to+attract+attention.+Marijuana+is+one+%5Bconcern%5D+in+Missouri+because+they%E2%80%99re+having+a+ballot+issue.+Illegal+immigration+and+cutting+taxes+are+the+ones+that+Republicans+use.+The+whole+%E2%80%98%5BRepublicans%5D+being+very+right-wing+and+autocratic%E2%80%99+is+%5Ban+issue+ad%5D+that+you+would+see+the+Democrats+doing.+They%E2%80%99re+all+over+the+place+depending+on+what+the+hot-button+issue+is%2C+social+studies+department+chair+Jeffrey+Chazen+said.
Elizabeth Franklin
This photo illustration is inspired by the copious political attack ads plastered over all news and local stations in the St. Louis Metro area. These commercials exploit current event issues by using the biggest concerns to attract attention. “Marijuana is one [concern] in Missouri because they’re having a ballot issue. Illegal immigration and cutting taxes are the ones that Republicans use. The whole ‘[Republicans] being very right-wing and autocratic’ is [an issue ad] that you would see the Democrats doing. They’re all over the place depending on what the hot-button issue is,” social studies department chair Jeffrey Chazen said.

On televisions across St. Louis, the faces of Democratic Senate candidate Trudy Busch Valentine and Republican Senate candidate Eric Schmitt were familiar ones from August to November. One moment, Valentine beamed in front of an inhumanly green pasture while melodic music floated in the air; the other, created by the Republican-backed Schmitt, featured dark, frantically clipped images of newspaper headlines seemingly backing up claims that she wants to ‘defund the police.’

Now, these claims were declared false, which means that even though the campaign teams didn’t have sufficient evidence for these accusations, they ran the ads anyway. These desperate, lying attack ads are hardly a Democrat vs. Republican thing — back in the 2022 Primaries, Valentine and opponent Lucas Kunce went through the same song and dance. One noteworthy attack ad by Valentine stated that Kunce was “against gay marriage,” “against Planned Parenthood,” and “for more jail time for marijuana,” which was proven false and condemned by the named source, Vote Smart.  

Now, a simple Google search would negate these fabrications. But advertisements are on the screen for a minute at most, and the majority of normal, everyday people don’t do their homework. With tiny, unexplained captions that “cite” their information, these campaign advertisements take advantage of the fact that there are no laws directly against misrepresenting the truth and aid in spreading misinformation.  

Political ad campaigns have only become more extreme over time, with candidates now spending an estimated $9 billion in advertising campaigns as of 2022. Strangely enough, political campaigns have not always been this way. Opponents have always attacked each other, sure, and they’ve always hit under the belt. However, this wave of sensationalized campaigning began with the introduction of the television in the 60s, sparking the current movement of gritty, black-and-white attack ads and the flurry of news and local stations overrun with smear campaigns, attempting to run the opponent into the ground. 

No surprise, the ad attacking an opponent or an issue distorts information of whichever side they disapprove; however, this also begins the process of misinformation by the way of campaign advertising. Even if political ads aren’t that effective, they can still stir up thoughts based on lies and misinform their audience. 

Most people don’t fact-check everything they hear, especially when these advertisements come during another activity, like watching television, scrolling on the internet or listening to the radio. Campaign teams capitalize on their audience’s inattention, utilizing current events and turning them into talking points that they spread rapidly, many times, without correctly using their cited sources. These tactics manipulate a gullible and naive audience to form unfounded beliefs about both ideas and people. 

“Truth can be muddled in those sorts of ads because [they’re] just trying to attack the other side, and it’s up to outside organizations to fact-check to see whether or not the ad is 100% correct,” social studies department chair Jeffrey Chazen said. “Sometimes, ads are just flat-out wrong, but they are effective because they made people think that [it was right].” 

Chazen teaches both Government and AP Government classes that are meant to prepare students for the future by educating them about civics and how government works. However, within the past ten to fifteen years, the rise of social media has interrupted this educational flow by the lack of differentiation between opinion and fact. As the so-called ‘marketplace of ideas,’ social media plays a heavy role in circulating false or sensationalized information, with fake news spreading more rapidly than real news

Media such as TikTok is praised for incorporating teaching methods, yet TikTok still has been approving ads that promote misinformation and amplifying fake news. Twitter is often used by many verifiable news sites, but there are only so many characters that someone can type into a Twitter post before the post is cut off — 280, to be exact — and this leads to short titles or explanations that do not encapsulate the true matter at hand. When audiences use social media solely for news, this leads to an overreliance on social media and overconfidence in how well people, especially students, can determine information from misinformation

Social media contributes largely to the misinformation and manipulation of viewers. A poll by Pew Research revealed that 31% of the interviewed adults receive their information from Facebook, while 25% of adults regularly receive their news from YouTube. However, social media platforms’ algorithms are often the cause of misinformation, especially about conspiracy theories, vaccines and the promotion of gender, racial or other identity-based hate.

It has been shown time and time again that misinformation not only causes miseducation but it can create real conflict. One well-known example lies within the escalated falsehoods about the election. Misinformation on social media sites like Twitter is widely regarded as the cause of the infamous Jan. 6 Capitol attacks and the numerous incidents after. In addition, with Twitter at their fingertips, commentators such as Tucker Carlson and Joe Rogan also contributed to the wide misleading information surrounding COVID-19, causing chaos and panic and even resulting in several further hospitalizations from ivermectin, which Rogan promoted on his podcast. Misinformation like this is dangerous and should be taken seriously. To demonstrate this, librarian Lauren Reusch evaluates websites with Honors English 2 students, teaching them how to identify and recognize misinformation.

“Social media, in particular, can be tailored to your preferences, which can become this echo chamber [where] we’re only seeing things that appeal to us,” Reusch said. “We’re not able to see all viewpoints and all sides of things because we’re only seeing the things that are curated for us, so it can be a dangerous place [for misinformation].”

The reasonable answer would be to say that misinformation needs to stop, and companies and campaigns that help to promote such misinformation and fake news need to be held accountable. However, we live in an unreasonable world with unreliable expectations, and thus, the burden falls on the incoming generations to reject this misinformation and maintain critical thinking skills. 

It sounds simple enough — at first. The truth is that with the increasing reliance on television and social media for information as well as the corporatization of so-called “real journalism,” it can be harder than ever to tell fact from fiction. 

Students of rising generations must learn to navigate through a world that constantly lies to them, which can be done in a multitude of ways. One of which involves challenging our inherent biases and exploring different perspectives on a topic to make a final decision on beliefs.

“If [an] article that you’re reading is reinforcing all the things that you believe, just remember that there’s another side out there,” Reusch said. “In order for us to be informed citizens, we have to understand both sides and [then] choose the side we want to [be] on.”

Furthermore, as much as people can over-depend on social media for news and opinions, technology can be a benefit. Taking time to gain knowledge about current events by researching constantly updated websites thoroughly vetted by professionals can prevent misinformation from taking root. Even opposite sides of the political spectrum still have verifiable, credible news sources that write in-depth, trustworthy stories and articles.

“Those [trusted news sources] are the ones that tend to have been around for a while,” Chazen said. “On the conservative side, the Wall Street Journal is a great organization. On the [liberal] side, the New York Times has been around for a while and is on a good track.”

It’s important to keep an open mind with statistics and the sources from whence they came, and, as information is updated, to know the right sources who have the credibility to report it. It is also important to question everything and make decisions about what is trustworthy based on past credibility, timeliness and the types of citations used. Social media and campaign ads purposely exploit inattentiveness, so it’s important to be involved and understand what’s true and what’s false. Some non-partisan platforms, such as Ground News and Politico, work to decrease the amount of false or severely biased disseminated information, which can limit the spread of such news.

Misinformation is not to be taken lightly. As students of a nation becoming increasingly partisan and digitized, we must understand and recognize the effects misinformation can have on not just individuals but a collective nation. We must learn to differentiate between fact and opinion and better evaluate the content we consume so that the media’s dirty, problematic tricks cannot manipulate us.

View Comments (5)
Donate to Pathfinder
$190
$800
Contributed
Our Goal

Your donation will support the student journalists of Parkway West High School. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.

More to Discover
About the Contributor
Elizabeth Franklin, Editor-in-Chief
Pronouns: she/her Grade: 12 Years on staff: 4 What is your favorite piece of literature?"Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry" is such a classic piece of literature that can still resonate with many people in the U.S. today. Cassie, the book’s protagonist was and is still refreshing to me: she’s a child, so the way that racism and discrimination impact her made it easy for me, also a child at the time, to understand some of the bigotry and prejudice that many of my ancestors faced, especially living in the South. Cassie’s a little spitfire, sure, but she’s also just a child, and at the end of the day, she embodies what America’s intrinsic racism can do to childish innocence like hers. Who is your hero? My hero is Ida B. Wells. She was an excellent journalist and was always dedicated to finding the truth, no matter the obstacles — and as a Black woman reporting in the South, she had a lot of obstacles. Although my journalistic career isn’t as nearly as dangerous as hers was, her work has paved the way for numerous other Black writers and journalists in the field, and it reminds me to always keep digging, even when the subjects are obscure or controversial in today’s overall political climate. If you could only eat one thing for the rest of your life, what would it be? I'm not going to lie, I could probably shovel down buckets of those Welch's fruit snacks.
Donate to Pathfinder
$190
$800
Contributed
Our Goal

Comments (5)

Please use your own name and keep your comments respectful!
All Pathfinder Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • M

    Mira NalbandianDec 7, 2022 at 4:32 pm

    Great job, Elizabeth!

    Reply
  • D

    Dr. PiffelNov 16, 2022 at 3:56 pm

    Thank you for writing this story, Elizabeth! I think it is important our students learn how information is monitored on various social media platforms and learn how to navigate trusted sources.

    Reply
  • K

    Katie WallaceNov 14, 2022 at 7:27 am

    This is such an informational, well-written story! Great job Elizabeth

    Reply
  • E

    Emily EarlyNov 9, 2022 at 10:41 am

    So well written. Great job, Elizabeth.

    Reply
  • A

    Audrey GhoshNov 9, 2022 at 8:30 am

    Love how timely and informational this is!

    Reply
Activate Search
The Official Student News Site of Parkway West High
They can’t be trusted