DESIGN SOLUTION: Offer multiple gender-neutral bathrooms throughout the school so that transgender, genderfluid and non-binary students have a bathroom to use.
One in four members of the LGBTQ+ community identifies as non-binary, genderfluid or transgender. Another source states that about 5.6% of the U.S. population is a part of the LGBTQ+ community, estimated at about 18 million people, increasing 1.1% from last year. Freshman Addi Bertz believes that this shows that society is changing and with that our social standards should be changing too. Bertz is cis-gendered, but still supports positive growth in the LGBTQ+ community and making the environment equally accommodating for everyone.
“Having two gender-specific bathrooms, just male and female has been around for a long time, and society is changing,” Bertz said. ”Things similar to that also have to change to make sure everyone is comfortable. Sometimes changes like this are required.”
The increasing population of the LGBTQ+ community supports conversations for gender-neutral bathrooms in schools, public buildings and places of work, as many people don’t associate with one gender. Because of this cause, transgender student, freshman Lu Schuetz started a petition for more gender-neutral bathrooms in school. For Schuetz, walking into a bathroom associated with birth gender feels weird, awkward and unsafe.
“[Using school] bathrooms makes me feel irritated or distressed. I often just wait until the end of the school day, when I can return home to use my bathroom where I can lock the door and be comfortable,” Schuetz said. “I have issues sometimes even going in public as [a transgender male] because there are people out there who don’t see us as normal. Being in a restroom is one of the places where you aren’t safe either way [because of] that discrimination.”
Freshman and transgender male Spade Shearer adds to Schuetz’s thoughts about feeling unsafe and agitated in school bathrooms. Both feel as if they have faced verbal harassment in bathrooms due to their gender, and even though they would prefer to use a bathroom that associates with their genders, Shearer feels as if that would create bigger problems.
“If someone sees me in a female bathroom, they are automatically going to assume that I am a female, and I am not,” Shearer said. “If the [gender neutral bathroom] is easy for me to access, I’ll use it. But I know that if I go to the guys’ bathroom, I could get in trouble for that, so I don’t use the school bathrooms at all.”
In order to help gain support for gender-neutral bathrooms in schools, Schuetz started a petition to help increase the number of gender-neutral bathrooms in Parkway Schools.
“These restrooms would be for people who aren’t cis-gendered or don’t want to use a bathroom specific to a gender. There’s a whole bunch of men’s and women’s bathrooms but there’s only one gender-neutral bathroom,” Shearer said. “It makes us more uncomfortable, especially because they are hidden away from the rest of the school and harder to access.”
Currently, the building has a single gender-neutral bathroom in the nurse’s office, at the front of the school entrance. Schuetz advocates for transitioning one current bathroom on each floor into a gender-neutral bathroom.
“I hope the petition gets more people to sign it. Someone defaced one of our petitions saying ‘boys will go in the boys, girls will go in the girls’ and it really hurt our feelings, so I am hoping if the school supports this plan, people will see the error of their ways,” Shearer said. “Hopefully [these bathrooms] will be normalized because explaining pronouns is uncomfortable and a lot of time I get ignored and people will continue to [refer to] me as a female.”
Those who argue against gender-neutral bathrooms say that students may take the room for granted, deface the property or violate school rules in these bathrooms by vaping, skipping class and smoking in the bathroom with little ability of enforcement. Shearer has difficulty understanding the argument made that adding a gender-neutral bathroom would negatively affect the school.
“I think it would be best if the school would start educating people on it. So instead of people thinking it’s funny, or weird, if they actually understand the importance behind these bathrooms then it would be a lot less of a risk to [transition] these bathrooms,” Shearer said.
If you are interested in signing this petition and helping Lu Schuetz raise awareness about the need for gender-neutral bathrooms, contact Lu Schuetz at [email protected], or go to the Keys Room 1518 to sign the petition.
carmelita • Nov 15, 2022 at 1:04 am
Where is the petition I wanna sign it website
Tanvi • Feb 9, 2022 at 7:15 am
Great article, Elle!
Ryan Whorton • Feb 8, 2022 at 6:25 pm
He created them male and female, and he blessed them and called them “human.”
Genesis 5:2
“Haven’t you read the Scriptures?” Jesus replied. “They record that from the beginning ‘God made them male and female.’”
Matthew 19:4
Going against our given gender is going against the one who gave us our gender. God made us male and female. If your a biological man, use the men’s restroom. If you’re a biological woman, use the women’s restroom.
Pao • Feb 9, 2022 at 11:06 am
bro if this article bothers you that much, why even read it AND leave an unnecessary comment. get a life
Ryan Whorton • Feb 11, 2022 at 10:31 am
Unnecessary? Am I not allowed to share a opinion? This article is stating both sides of an opinion. This school is my home and I’m allowed to share my opinion just as much as anyone.
Serena • Feb 11, 2022 at 4:13 pm
Biological sex and gender are different. I respect your religious beliefs, but you have to understand that gender consists of the social and cultural aspects of how you choose to express yourself. It’s completely separate from sex and everyone has the freedom to choose how they want to manifest their gender.
Furthermore, even biological sex is not binary. I recommend looking into DSDs and people with intersex traits if you want a better understanding of the beauty of human diversity. So, we should support the people around us and try our best to make everyone feel loved and included. https://hms.harvard.edu/magazine/lgbtq-health/body-self
Brinda • Feb 12, 2022 at 12:20 pm
While you might follow these religious beliefs, and as Serena said I respect that, other people do not have the same beliefs as you. Public school is about making sure everyone is comfortable and included from a secular standpoint.
Moreover, it might help to understand the journeys other people go through especially when we might not go through them ourselves. Novels such as None of the Above, Middlesex, and Stay Gold tell these stories. Even if you don’t agree, it can’t hurt to learn more about the other side. If you’re truly right, it’ll only strengthen your belief.
Ryan Whorton • Feb 12, 2022 at 9:47 pm
To you and Serena, thank you for the respectful discussion over it. When I posted this comment, I was saying it respectfully and to potentially start a discussion so I do just want to say thanks to both of you for respecting that. I am all for discussing both sides of this opinion.
Serena • Feb 14, 2022 at 8:43 am
I appreciate that you are willing to start a discussion, and I would love to further discuss this issue with you, but I feel as though your initial comment was disrespecting the identity of many students in our community. The article describes how some LGBTQ+ students feel awkward, distressed and unsafe when using a bathroom associated with their birth sex, and I just think that saying “If [you’re] a biological man, use the men’s restroom. If you’re a biological woman, use the women’s restroom” is inherently disrespectful. Although you may believe that you were being respectful, your statement just completely invalidates their emotions and life experience because of your own religious beliefs. I am Christian myself, but religion is never an excuse to make other people feel uncomfortable or unsafe.